Tag Archives: caps on tort claims

Indiana Tort Claims Against Governmental Entities and Their Employees

This article is Part I of a series. It addresses the principal of sovereign immunity and reform of English common law, specifically caps on tort claims against Indiana governmental entities and their employees. Part II will focus on tort reform in Indiana for medical malpractice claims.

History of Sovereign Immunity

Call personal injury and accident lawyer Charlie Ward today for a free consultation

Hoosiers have been privy to considerable discussion lately about caps on tort claims. The conversations have focused primarily around the 2011 Indiana State Fair stage collapse. To add insight into the laws that we live and abide by in the state of Indiana, I thought this would be a good time to explain the $5,000,000 state fund made available for tort claimants and how this incident has spawned controversy in the legal and legislative communities as well as among the public in general.

Up until the 1940’s, American sovereign immunity protected nearly every national, state and local governmental entity and their employees from being sued. The principal of Sovereign Immunity stems from the English common law—upon which our American legal system is founded—wherein the sovereign “King could do no wrong” and therefore, could not be sued by his subjects without first extending his permission. However, during the mid-twentieth century a trend toward government accountability began to emerge and the federal government passed the Federal Tort Claims Act (28 U.S.C. §2674), waiving immunity and liability for certain actions.

Then in 1969 the Indiana State Supreme Court ruled on behalf of plaintiffs (Perkins v. State) who had become ill from lake water contaminated with raw sewage while they were renting a cottage located on state property. With regards to the doctrine of sovereign immunity, Judge Arterburn of the Indiana Supreme Court wrote:

“…law is active and dynamic and thus changes with the times and growth of society to meet its needs”.

In his opinion, Judge Arterburn believed the principles of law on which a court rested a previous decision “…do not prevent the courts from ever changing the common law, but the common law must grow and develop with the growth of our society in which it operates.”

Three years later Judge Arterburn in Campbell v. State of Indiana affirmed that the State, acting in a proprietary activity, “…could not avail itself of the immunity privilege.”

Indiana Tort Claims Act

In 1974 the Indiana State General Assembly enacted legislation entitled the Indiana Tort Claims Act. The law currently in place, Indiana Code, Chapter 3, Section 4 addresses the $700,000 cap per claimant, a $5,000,000 limitation on the aggregate liability for all claimants, and prohibits punitive damage awards. Although the individual awards for personal injury claimants have been increased by legislative amendments over the years, the total cap of $5,000,000 liability, per incident, to settle wrongful death and personal injury claims has remained the same since 1974.

In light of the facts, attorneys and legislators are re-thinking the decades old cap and its ability to address the scope of this situation.  Already one attorney has filed suit claiming the cap denies individuals their fair share and creates an economic incentive for the state to act negligently. Many believe the caps are arbitrary; that every claim is unique and requires a case-by-case approach. But in the end, it is likely that the legislature will have their say as well.

Charlie Ward is a personal injury attorney experienced in accident litigation and wrongful death claims. The law office of Ward & Ward receives no legal fees or expenses unless we collect damages on your behalf. Call Charlie today at 317-639-9501 to discuss your accident and receive a free analysis of your claim.

Charlie Ward

317-639-9501

www.wardlawfirm.com

Punitive Damages Awards in the State of Indiana

Indianapolis IN Accident Attorney

Punitive damage awards meant to halt bad behavior

Punitive damages are monetary awards that extend beyond compensation for an individual’s economic and non-economic damages. A wrongful act performed with a sincere intention to deal fairly with others is an inadequate basis for such an award. Punitive damages awards are used as a tool of the legal system to thwart outrageous or egregious conduct; the evidence must demonstrate that the offender’s behavior was intentionally willful, wanton or reckless using the following guidelines:

  • Willfulness implies intent to commit a wrongdoing which causes harm to another. For example, if a manufacturer knows that their goods could cause injury but chooses not to modify their product because of the cost, then that person or entity’s conduct can be deemed “willful”;
  • Wanton conduct is acting with a reckless indifference to the consequences and the disregard to another’s well-being; and
  • An act of recklessness is performed with a complete disregard of a predictable injurious outcome.

Caps on punitive damage awards in Indiana

Call Charlie Ward at 317-639-9501

In Indiana, the legislature has limited the maximum amount allowable in cases of punitive damage awards. Indiana Code 34-51-3-4 §4 states:

A punitive damage award may not be more than the greater of:

  1. Three (3) times the amount of compensatory damages awarded in the action; or
  2. Fifty thousand dollars ($50,000).

            As added by P.L.1-1998, SEC.47.

Distribution of Punitive Damage Award

In IC 34-51-3-6, the person to whom the punitive damages were awarded will receive 25% of the award and the remaining 75% will be deposited by the Indiana State Treasurer into the violent crimes victim’s compensation fund with an option for the State Attorney General to negotiate and compromise the State of Indiana’s 75% portion of the punitive damage award.

Experienced Personal Injury and Product Liability Attorneys

If you or someone you know has been injured in an accident, it’s important to speak with an experienced personal injury lawyer. The law firm of Ward & Ward has over 85 years of combined experience in personal injury law including car, motorcycle, trucking accidents and wrongful death claims. Our firm receives no legal fees or expenses unless we collect damages on your behalf. Call Charlie Ward today at 317-639-9501 for a free evaluation of your claim.

By Charlie Ward

Ward & Ward Law Firm
728 S Meridian St
Indianapolis, IN 46225
317-639-9501